Ministers in U-turn on shock therapy

By Marie Woolf and Sophie Goodchild
Published: 17 June 2007
The Independent

A government U-turn tomorrow will herald huge improvements in mental- health treatment for young people. In a series of compromise changes to its controversial Mental Health Bill, the Government will curb the use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) on teenagers and ensure they do not have to share wards with adults, who are often disturbed and dangerous.

As the Bill reaches a crunch phase in the Commons, amendments will mean no child under 18 will be givenECT without a second opinion from a doctor. Children must also be treated in an environment appropriate for their age.

The U-turns follow criticism from a powerful coalition of mental health charities, psychiatrists, MPs and peers, who tore apart the Bill with a series of amendments. The Independent on Sunday has highlighted opposition to the Bill for five years.

Ministers are said to be ready for a “dog fight” over parts of the Bill they refused to compromise on, such as the definition of mental illness. The Mental Health Alliance welcomed the changes but said the Bill was still “not fit for the 21st century”.

Comments (1)

steve taylorJanuary 29th, 2008 at 9:12 am

The new mental health act in the uk has actually gone much further in limiting the use of ECT. ECT will not be able to be given to detained patients if they do not consent to the treatment and have mental capacity. Nor can ECT be given to patients without capacity (whether detained or not) if an advance decision refusing ECT (under the Mental Capacity Act) has been made.

Please note, these changes do not become statute until October, 2008

Leave a comment

Your comment:

Subscribe without commenting