Ask a QuestionDonate

Can a Catholic Accept the Theory of Evolution?

I. Introduction

The question of whether what we know by revelation (theological doctrine) is compatible with what we know from observation and experience (saliently, if not exclusively, the natural sciences) was already topical in the age of St. Augustine. It became so again in the Middle Ages when the doctrine of the world having a beginning in time (creatio ab initio temporis) confronted Aristotelian eternalism. And so, when John Ruskin wrote (in 1851), “If only the Geologists would let me alone, I could do very well, but those dreadful Hammers! I hear the clink of them at the end of every cadence of the Bible verses,”{1} he was only rearticulating a concern that had made intermittent reappearances for over a thousand years. The problem was only reinforced by the emergence, within a decade, of a scientifically well-developed evolutionary account of the origin of biological species, an idea that has worried some Christians from then until our own day. It need not do so.

II. What Is Evolution?

Nineteenth-century philosopher William Whewell pointed out that, in typological contrast to sciences like Isaac Newton’s physics or John Dalton’s chemical atomism, some kinds of science (“paleoetiological” sciences) “contemplate the universe, the earth, and its inhabitants, with reference to their historical changes and the causes of those changes,” adding that “[their] object is, to ascend from the present state of things to a more ancient condition, from which the present is derived by intelligible causes.”{2} Such theories have been advanced in a variety of sciences, from cosmology to historical linguistics.

Charles Darwin’s idea that the present diversity of biological species is the result of descent, with differential modification, from one or a few first kinds{3} is an example of such a paleoetiological theory, indeed the one which the term “evolution” itself generally calls to mind. Still, it cannot be denied that different people mean different things by the word “evolution.” St. John Paul II once referred to “theories of evolution,” saying that “the use of the plural is required here—in part because of the diversity of explanations regarding the mechanism of evolution, and in part because of the diversity of philosophies involved.”{4}

Concretely, some people build into the term “evolution” some mixture of a relatively comprehensive scope—“a cosmical process, one and continuous from nebula to man, from star to soul, from atom to society”{5}—and a quasi-metaphysical naturalist, and anti-providentialist, philosophy of nature—“pure chance, absolutely free but blind [as] at the very root of the stupendous edifice of evolution.”{6} Other people, claiming that the theory of evolution has now been rejected, in the end turn out to mean by it just a very particular version of the evolutionary origin of biological species.

Here I will use the term to mean just the Darwinian thesis mentioned above, one which has no necessary connection to the problematic philosophies of nature and which (as an account of what has happened) has survived over a century of further scientific research even if our understanding of exactly how it works continues to evolve.

III. Is Evolution a Fact or a Theory?

These two terms—fact and theory—are also used variously.

In popular discourse, they are often used to contrast settled points (“That’s a fact!”) and contested or even relatively unsupported ones (“That’s just a theory!”). So, “theory,” or equivalently “hypothesis,” ends up something of a synonym for “opinion” or even “mere conjecture.”

In scientific contexts, the two terms are most commonly used rather to contrast something in need of an explanation (an explanandum) and the explanation itself. That explanandum could be a relatively particular observation (e.g., Mars has an elliptical orbit), a generalized one (a “law,” e.g., Kepler’s Laws), or even a low-level explanation (e.g., Galileo’s theory of projectile motion). Such explanations are sometimes so well supported by evidence (e.g., heliocentric astronomy) that they cease to be contested without ever being directly observed. That makes them theories and facts, albeit according to different ways of using such terms.

So, though it may be a paradox, it is not an inconsistency to say that evolution is both a theory and a fact. It is essentially, and will always be, a theory in virtue of its inherent explanatory function. Its broad explanatory scope (ranging from paleontology and biogeography to comparative anatomy and embryology) has secured it the general acceptance among scientists that makes it reasonable now to denominate it a fact.

IV. Is Evolution Consistent with the Doctrine of Creation?

The general ideas of evolution and creation are compatible. God could have created an evolving world. The idea of an evolving world itself leaves entirely open the question of whether that world was also a created one. Evolution is a theory of change, of how some species are transformed into other species; creation, by contrast, in the sense at the heart of Catholic theological doctrine, is not a theory of change at all, but rather an account of the production of something ex nihilo and a conservation of that product in being.

The idea that the products of a natural process of evolution (not only Dan Patch, but the equine species itself) can still be said to be created can be preserved by making a distinction between an absolute creation and a derivative one.

Sacred Scripture does not say that God created biological species ex nihilo. About plants and brute animals it says explicitly that God commanded the earth and the waters to bring them forth. Even the idea of an evolutionary origin of the human body, at least when supplemented by positing the creation of the first human soul, respects the relevant passages of Genesis 1–2. It is an account of the origin of the first human beings analogous to what we must say about the origin of every human being—namely, that natural processes produce material bodies into which created souls are infused.

V. What Has the Magisterium Said about Evolution?

On the question of the scientific theories of the origin of biological species other than man, since there is no conflict between the theory of evolution and her doctrine of creation, the Church is silent. God did not establish a Church to resolve purely scientific controversies, resolution being generally within the reach of human intellectual powers and, for the most part, not relevant to our salvation.

The materialist and reductionist components of ideas that are sometimes passed off as “theories of evolution,” and claimed to have the authority of science, do, of course, by contrast, as St. John Paul II added in the address quoted above, place “the final judgment [on those ideas] within the competence of philosophy and, beyond that, of theology.”

On the question of the origin of man, i.e., of the very first human persons, however much the evidence makes an evolutionary origin of the human body scientifically plausible and theologically unproblematic, the doctrine of the direct creation of each human soul makes the theory of evolution insufficient as a full account of that origin.

Some critics have argued that Catholic doctrine requires (as a consequence of its account of original sin), and the scientific theory of evolutionary anthropogenesis precludes, there being a single couple of first human beings from whom all other human beings are descended (monogenesis). The allegation that there is a contradiction here fails to recognize that a scientific theory can offer an account only of the first human body (not of the full, ensouled, human person); theology, by contrast, is interested precisely in the origin of human persons, composites of a material body and an immaterial soul, not in whether the bodily part of that human person evolved from an animal or was formed directly from mud.

VI. The Importance of the Question

Understanding that the connection between science and theology on the question of origins is complementary rather than contradictory has some importance to the extent that it emerges in the context of natural curiosity about the origin of the human race and indeed of the natural world itself.

It is perhaps particularly important because some atheists continue to argue that the theory of evolution constitutes a refutation of the doctrine of creation, and indeed of Christianity itself. It is also important because some Catholics have continued to insist on the incompatibility of the two ideas, placing a needless obstacle to faith both for cradle Catholics and for potential converts.

 

Further Reading: Nicanor Pier Giorgio Austriaco, O.P., et al., Thomistic Evolution: A Catholic Approach to Understanding Evolution in the Light of Faith, 2nd ed. (Cluny, 2019); Nicanor Pier Giorgio Austriaco, O.P., et al., Creation through Evolution: New Perspectives from Thomistic Philosophy and Theology (Catholic University of America Press, 2025); Kenneth W. Kemp, The Origins of Catholic Evolutionism, 1832–1950 (Catholic University of America Press, 2025); Daniel Kuebler, Darwin and Doctrine: The Compatibility of Evolution and Catholicism (Word on Fire, 2025).


{1} Letter of Ruskin to Henry Acland, Works of John Ruskin, ed. E. T. Cook and Alexander Wedderburn (Longmans, Green, 1903–12), 36:114–15.

{2} Whewell, History of the Inductive Sciences, 3rd ed. (Parker, 1866), 1:488 and 2:499.

{3} The phrase is adapted only slightly from Charles Darwin’s Origin of Species (Murray, 1859), 483.

{4} John Paul II, “Message to Pontifical Academy of Sciences on Evolution,” Origins: CNS Documentary Service 26, no. 25 (1996): 414–16 (italics added).

{5} Grant Allen, Charles Darwin (Longmans, 1885), 191.

{6} Jacques Monod, Chance and Necessity (Vintage, 1971), 112.

This printed version is not intended for academic citation. For a citable version of this response, download the PDF at ect.org.

About the Author

Kenneth W. Kemp

Kenneth W. Kemp is Professor Emeritus of Philosophy at the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota.

Ask a scholar

Have a question about this response?

Send us a question on any topic covered in the encyclopedia. Selected questions will be answered in our Responses section.

Submit a question →
Can a Catholic Accept Evolution? | Encyclopedia of Catholic Theology