The confession of sins in the sacrament of Penance constitutes the ordinary means by which grave post-baptismal sins are remitted. Indeed, the 1983 Code of Canon Law explains: “Individual and integral confession and absolution constitute the only ordinary means by which a member of the faithful conscious of grave sin is reconciled with God and the Church” (CIC, can. 960). In this context, “integral” refers to the confession of each grave sin in its kind and number. Integrity refers to a confession’s completeness regarding the sins committed (and not yet remitted in the sacrament of Penance). How priests can assist penitents to make integral confessions remains a delicate matter that requires due consideration.
The reason the Church recognizes the integrity of a confession to be a requirement of the divine law follows from the nature of the sacrament itself. In Confession, through the absolution of the priest, God forgives sins, offers an infusion of his grace, and reconciles a baptized sinner with the Church (CCC, no. 1468). Through the commission of each and every grave sin, a person suffers a wound that stands in need of healing. Those wounds remain distinct depending on the nature of each sin committed. In addition, the wound is deepened by the number of times each grave sin was committed.
For example, adultery represents a different species of sin than simple fornication. The violation of a spouse in marital infidelity represents a defective act distinct from the illicit choice (by unmarried persons) for sexual pleasure apart from a marital union. In a similar way, the theft of a chalice constitutes not merely an injustice toward another person but a sacrilegious theft, a unique species of sin. The reason for the need to confess in this integral way becomes apparent when one recognizes what the sacrament accomplishes. The graces of this sacrament of healing penetrate the human soul. The sacrilegious thief needs healing both of his disordered attachment to material things and of his insufficient religious sense about the things of God. He is, properly speaking, both irreligious toward God and unjust regarding a neighbor’s goods. Confessions need to be integral to express sorrow for each sin committed. God’s healing grace restores the sinner in each area wounded by sin.
Catholic theologians distinguish between material and formal integrity regarding the sacrament of Penance. Put simply, the goal of every confession is that it be materially integral, that is, the confession of every grave post-baptismal sin in kind and number. However, formal integrity, that is, an honest, best effort to confess one’s sins as one is conscious of them, suffices for a valid administration of the sacrament. Truth to tell, the Church recognizes this dispensation of the divine grace when she explains that in some cases the confession of sin may be generic. See the Order of the Anointing of the Sick and of Their Pastoral Care, no. 104: “in case of necessity, [the confession] may even be generic, if it cannot be done in another way.”
Those who attempt to confess their sins honestly but lack the training to distinguish adequately one species of sin from another nonetheless confess validly. This represents a distinct case from one who intentionally withholds a grave sin and thus confesses in a dishonest or truncated way.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church alludes to this distinction between material and formal integrity when it teaches: “When Christ’s faithful strive to confess all the sins that they can remember, they undoubtedly place all of them before the divine mercy for pardon. But those who fail to do so and knowingly withhold some, place nothing before the divine goodness for remission through the mediation of the priest, ‘for if the sick person is too ashamed to show his wound to the doctor, the medicine cannot heal what it does not know’” (CCC, no. 1456).
A priest may offer assistance for a penitent to make a more integral confession. In the moment of a particular confession, the priest can encourage a penitent to more fully examine his or her conscience and might even lead a penitent through the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue. However, he also must be careful not to introduce new sins to a penitent who may not have committed them or, in some cases, even be aware of them. He also must ensure that each penitent has an apparent experience of God’s mercy. The confessional is not a torture chamber, as Pope Francis explained. It is important that whatever instruction the priest gives illuminate and not obscure the mercy of God available in the sacrament.
Instruction on how to make an integral confession most often takes place outside the sacrament of Penance. What is needed today is greater formation to receive this sacrament and specifically on how to confess integrally. The Catholic people benefit from such instruction and would find their confessions more fruitful the more they recognized the need to confess with a greater degree of integrity.
Some may question—with unfounded fear—whether focus on the integrity of confessions could dissuade people from confessing at all. The truth is that people stand in need of relief from their sins. Insofar as they are aware of them, they will benefit from confessing them with precision. Extraneous details that make no difference to the nature or number of sins committed should not be mentioned. But Catholics should rejoice in the mercy of God available to them when they confess their sins as best they are able. At the same time, Catholic priests need not worry that honest but poorly instructed penitents are making invalid confessions. Rather, such persons stand in need of further counsel, most often outside of the sacrament of Penance.
Further reading: Ryan Connors, “The Riches of God’s Mercy: Five Neglected Truths about the Sacrament of Penance,” Antiphon 27.3 (2023): 333–48; John A. McHugh, OP, and Charles J. Callan, OP, Moral Theology: A Complete Course, vol. 2 (Joseph F. Wagner, Inc., 1958), especially §§2728 and 2743; and Romanus Cessario, OP, The Seven Sacraments of the Catholic Church (Baker Academic, 2023).
This printed version is not intended for academic citation. For a citable version of this response, download the PDF at ect.org.
The Reverend Ryan Connors is Rector of the Seminary of Our Lady of Providence in Providence, Rhode Island.
Send us a question on any topic covered in the encyclopedia. Selected questions will be answered in our Responses section.
Submit a question →